353,430
edits
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
(8 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
Every person has their own opinions about which pop'n music game is the "best". Rather than point out a definitive list, this page will list the pros and cons of each one, and let you decide. It is easier, however, to get the newer mixes. | Every person has their own opinions about which pop'n music game is the "best". Rather than point out a definitive list, this page will list the pros and cons of each one, and let you decide. It is easier, however, to get the newer mixes. | ||
''In the case of [[ | ''In the case of [[CS pnm portable 2|pop'n music portable 2]]'s DLC content, songs from there will count against mixes that had the song originally unique in it.'' | ||
=== [[ | === [[CS pnm|pop'n music CS]] === | ||
'''Total Songs:''' 19<br> | '''Total Songs:''' 19<br> | ||
Line 19: | Line 19: | ||
* Only 19 songs, all available in the sequel and some other games. | * Only 19 songs, all available in the sequel and some other games. | ||
* Only three songs have more than one chart, and you must unlock all the songs in the game to play them. | * Only three songs have more than one chart, and you must unlock all the songs in the game to play them. | ||
* Omits features such as records and | * Omits features such as records and [[KEY DISC]]. | ||
* Incredibly dated graphics/interface. | * Incredibly dated graphics/interface. | ||
* Bad loading times on the PlayStation version. | * Bad loading times on the PlayStation version. | ||
=== [[ | === [[CS pnm 2|pop'n music 2 CS]] === | ||
'''Total Songs:''' 46<br> | '''Total Songs:''' 46<br> | ||
Line 31: | Line 31: | ||
* Available on Dreamcast and PlayStation. | * Available on Dreamcast and PlayStation. | ||
* Both versions include ''pop'n music anywhere'', a lightweight version of pop'n music for the VMU and PocketStation, respectively. (These special memory cards are sold separately.) | * Both versions include ''pop'n music anywhere'', a lightweight version of pop'n music for the VMU and PocketStation, respectively. (These special memory cards are sold separately.) | ||
* | * KEY DISC, which can be used to play the later [[APPEND DISC]] games with. | ||
* Introduces many of the characters still seen in the series today. | * Introduces many of the characters still seen in the series today. | ||
* Difficulty level has been amped, and a very few amount of songs even | * Difficulty level has been amped, and a very few amount of songs even have a second chart. | ||
'''Cons''' | '''Cons''' | ||
Line 41: | Line 40: | ||
* Still only one difficulty level for most songs. | * Still only one difficulty level for most songs. | ||
=== [[ | === [[CS pnm 3|pop'n music 3 APPEND DISC]] === | ||
'''Total Songs:''' 44<br> | '''Total Songs:''' 44<br> | ||
Line 49: | Line 48: | ||
* Available on Dreamcast and PlayStation. | * Available on Dreamcast and PlayStation. | ||
* More songs have second charts than the previous game. | * More songs have second charts than the previous game. | ||
* Some older songs have new | * Some older songs have new HYPER charts to play. | ||
'''Cons''' | '''Cons''' | ||
* Outdated graphics, bad loading times still. | * Outdated graphics, bad loading times still. | ||
* | * Old songs with new HYPER charts have only them, and not their original chart as well. | ||
* Requires KEY DISC to play. | |||
* | * Three missing licenses. | ||
* Three | |||
* Out of print. | * Out of print. | ||
=== [[ | === [[CS pnm 4|pop'n music 4 APPEND DISC]] === | ||
'''Total Songs:''' 41<br> | '''Total Songs:''' 41<br> | ||
Line 69: | Line 67: | ||
* All but five of the songs are new to the game. | * All but five of the songs are new to the game. | ||
* Several of the arcade originals have never been revived. | * Several of the arcade originals have never been revived. | ||
* Two of the licenses missing from | * Two of the licenses missing from the previous CS game are restored in this one. | ||
'''Cons''' | '''Cons''' | ||
* Very few unlocks, most of them remixes. (Only one is a CS song.) | * Very few unlocks, most of them remixes. (Only one is a CS song.) | ||
* | * Requires KEY DISC to play. | ||
* Out of print and harder to find. | * Out of print and harder to find. | ||
=== [[ | === [[CS pnm 5|pop'n music 5 CS]] === | ||
'''Total Songs:''' 64<br> | '''Total Songs:''' 64<br> | ||
Line 86: | Line 84: | ||
* Contains 15 brand-new songs for the CS release, a standard followed in nearly every game since. | * Contains 15 brand-new songs for the CS release, a standard followed in nearly every game since. | ||
* Much improved graphics and interface. | * Much improved graphics and interface. | ||
* Features | * Features HI-SPEED 3 and 4 from [[AC pnm 6|pop'n music 6]]. | ||
'''Cons''' | '''Cons''' | ||
* Hard to find and expensive. | * Hard to find and expensive. | ||
* All but | * All but three of the arcade songs have been in later games. | ||
* Unlocking system has ridiculous requirements. | * Unlocking system has ridiculous requirements. | ||
=== [[ | === [[CS pnm 6|pop'n music 6 CS]] === | ||
'''Total Songs:''' 104<br> | '''Total Songs:''' 104<br> | ||
Line 99: | Line 97: | ||
'''Pros''' | '''Pros''' | ||
* Biggest | * Biggest song list of the PS1 games, bigger than some of the PS2 games. | ||
* All the new AC/CS songs (not counting pop'n stage songs) have Hyper difficulty as the minimum difficulty level: a first. | * All the new AC/CS songs (not counting pop'n stage songs) have Hyper difficulty as the minimum difficulty level: a first. | ||
* Introduces the first "modern" looking in-game interface, featuring lanes separated by color for the first time. | * Introduces the first "modern" looking in-game interface, featuring lanes separated by color for the first time. | ||
* Contains (nearly) the entire [[pop'n stage Information|pop'n stage]] | * Contains (nearly) the entire [[pop'n stage Information|pop'n stage]] song list as a bonus. | ||
'''Cons''' | '''Cons''' | ||
* Hard to find and expensive. | * Hard to find and expensive. | ||
* Long loading times for selecting your song in | * BPM is still missing in-game, much like the arcade release, requiring you to memorize song BPMs. | ||
* Long loading times for selecting your song in ARCADE. | |||
* Graphic quality is diminished greatly from the arcade version, with animation on par with the first games. | * Graphic quality is diminished greatly from the arcade version, with animation on par with the first games. | ||
* Songs exclusive to | * Songs exclusive to EXPERT only have one chart, even if they originally had more than one. | ||
* Several modes from the arcade version were cut out, most noticeably | * Several modes from the arcade version were cut out, most noticeably BATTLE and [[RGB Mode]]. | ||
* All but | * All but two licenses are missing from the arcade version. | ||
=== [[ | === [[CS pnm 7|pop'n music 7 CS]] === | ||
'''Total Songs:''' 97<br> | '''Total Songs:''' 97<br> | ||
Line 118: | Line 117: | ||
'''Pros''' | '''Pros''' | ||
* Difficulty level is higher than previous games, with many more EX | * Difficulty level is higher than previous games, with many more EX charts than the last 2 games. | ||
* Lots of new | * Lots of new songs. | ||
* Part of the | * Part of the Best Hits line, making it inexpensive to purchase new. | ||
* Unlike | * Unlike pop'n music 6 CS, all songs are playable in every mode. | ||
'''Cons''' | '''Cons''' | ||
* Increasingly harder to find new. | * Increasingly harder to find new. | ||
* Two missing licenses. | * Two missing licenses. | ||
* | * Song list is hit or miss for some. | ||
* Interface is often criticized as being difficult to navigate through. | * Interface is often criticized as being difficult to navigate through. | ||
* Many of the new songs were repeated in the next game. | * Many of the new songs were repeated in the next game. | ||
=== [[ | === [[CS pnm Best_Hits|pop'n music Best Hits!]] === | ||
'''Total Songs:''' 54<br> | '''Total Songs:''' 54<br> | ||
Line 138: | Line 137: | ||
* Contains many songs that haven't been revived since their appearance in this game. | * Contains many songs that haven't been revived since their appearance in this game. | ||
* Many of the songs and charts are available from the get-go. | * Many of the songs and charts are available from the get-go. | ||
* Contains missing licenses from [[ | * Contains missing licenses from [[AC pnm 6|pop'n music 6]]. | ||
* Only PS2 appearance of many older pop'n music characters for play. | * Only PS2 appearance of many older pop'n music characters for play. | ||
'''Cons''' | '''Cons''' | ||
* Hard to find and expensive. | * Hard to find and expensive. | ||
* Small | * Small song list compared to other PlayStation 2 and even PlayStation pop'n music titles. | ||
* Only | * Only five new songs, three of them remixes. | ||
* Many of these songs can already be played in | * Many of these songs can already be played in 6 and 7 CS. | ||
=== [[ | === [[CS pnm 8|pop'n music 8 CS]] === | ||
'''Total Songs:''' 104<br> | '''Total Songs:''' 104<br> | ||
Line 153: | Line 152: | ||
'''Pros''' | '''Pros''' | ||
* Big, varied | * Big, varied song list. | ||
* Many of the songs have not repeated to this day. | * Many of the songs have not repeated to this day. | ||
* Part of the PS2 Best Hits line, making it inexpensive to purchase new. | * Part of the PS2 Best Hits line, making it inexpensive to purchase new. | ||
* First (mainline) CS game with an unlocking system, making for faster progression. | |||
'''Cons''' | '''Cons''' | ||
Line 164: | Line 162: | ||
* Cumbersome interface. | * Cumbersome interface. | ||
=== [[ | === [[CS pnm 9|pop'n music 9 CS]] === | ||
'''Total Songs:''' 111<br> | '''Total Songs:''' 111<br> | ||
Line 173: | Line 171: | ||
* Good balance between easy and difficult songs. | * Good balance between easy and difficult songs. | ||
* Much less cumbersome interface than 8. | * Much less cumbersome interface than 8. | ||
* Contains 4 [[ee'MALL]] songs and 3 preview songs from [[ | * Contains 4 [[ee'MALL]] songs and 3 preview songs from [[AC pnm 10|pop'n music 10]]. | ||
* A record 22 new CS songs, more than any other installment in the series. (Not counting Long Versions or earlier CS songs.) | * A record 22 new CS songs, more than any other installment in the series. (Not counting Long Versions or earlier CS songs.) | ||
* First CS pop'n title with Hi-Speed 6. | * First CS pop'n title with Hi-Speed 6. | ||
* Only appearance of Hi-Speed 8. | * Only appearance of Hi-Speed 8. | ||
* Only CS pop'n title to contain Long Version songs. | * Only CS pop'n title to contain Long Version songs. | ||
* Part of the | * Part of the Best Hits line, making it inexpensive to purchase new. | ||
'''Cons''' | '''Cons''' | ||
Line 185: | Line 183: | ||
* Much slower speed mods than the rest of the series. | * Much slower speed mods than the rest of the series. | ||
=== [[ | === [[CS pnm 10|pop'n music 10 CS]] === | ||
'''Total Songs:''' 103<br> | '''Total Songs:''' 103<br> | ||
Line 192: | Line 190: | ||
'''Pros''' | '''Pros''' | ||
* Upped difficulty from previous games. | * Upped difficulty from previous games. | ||
* | * Songs no longer have to be unlocked one at a time in FREE, nor do all EX charts have to be unlocked one by one as well anymore. | ||
* Interface is more polished than earlier games. | * Interface is more polished than earlier games. | ||
* Part of the | * Part of the Best Hits line, making it inexpensive to purchase new. | ||
'''Cons''' | '''Cons''' | ||
Line 201: | Line 199: | ||
* Timing is incredibly strict/off. | * Timing is incredibly strict/off. | ||
=== [[ | === [[CS pnm 11|pop'n music 11 CS]] === | ||
'''Total Songs:''' 113<br> | '''Total Songs:''' 113<br> | ||
Line 208: | Line 206: | ||
'''Pros''' | '''Pros''' | ||
* First game with Hi-Speed 5. | * First game with Hi-Speed 5. | ||
* Big, varied | * Big, varied song list. | ||
* Only CS pop'n title with URA notecharts. | * Only CS pop'n title with URA notecharts. | ||
'''Cons''' | '''Cons''' | ||
* Expensive to purchase (not part of the | * Expensive to purchase (not part of the Best Hits line). | ||
* URA charts are hit or miss with players. | * URA charts are hit or miss with players. | ||
* Very long unlock system, time unlocks or otherwise. | * Very long unlock system, time unlocks or otherwise. | ||
=== [[ | === [[CS pnm 12|pop'n music 12 いろは CS]] === | ||
'''Total Songs:''' 102<br> | '''Total Songs:''' 102<br> | ||
Line 222: | Line 220: | ||
'''Pros''' | '''Pros''' | ||
* Varied | * Varied song list. | ||
* Easy, fun unlocking system. | * Easy, fun unlocking system. | ||
* | * pop'n Request songs. | ||
'''Cons''' | '''Cons''' | ||
* Three songs require data from other PlayStation 2 | * Three songs require data from other PlayStation 2 BEMANI games to save permanently (outside of rather annoying unlock requirements). | ||
* Many of the songs were later repeated in the next game. | * Many of the songs were later repeated in the next game. | ||
* Older songs have awkward timing. | * Older songs have awkward timing. | ||
=== [[ | === [[CS pnm 13|pop'n music 13 カーニバル CS]] === | ||
'''Total Songs:''' 114<br> | '''Total Songs:''' 114<br> | ||
Line 239: | Line 237: | ||
* Super Challenge mode added to gameplay. | * Super Challenge mode added to gameplay. | ||
* Fast unlocking system. | * Fast unlocking system. | ||
* | * pop'n Request songs. | ||
* Lots of songs, many of them brand-new to the game. | * Lots of songs, many of them brand-new to the game. | ||
'''Cons''' | '''Cons''' | ||
* Lots of repeats from the previous game. | * Lots of repeats from the previous game. | ||
* Mini-game very frustrating to complete, and is required to play one of the songs outside of Marathon Mode. | * Mini-game very frustrating to complete, and is required to play one of the songs outside of completing Marathon Mode. | ||
=== [[ | === [[CS pnm 14|pop'n music 14 FEVER! CS]] === | ||
'''Total Songs:''' 112<br> | '''Total Songs:''' 112<br> | ||
Line 256: | Line 254: | ||
* New mini-games to play (not required to play it to unlock songs). | * New mini-games to play (not required to play it to unlock songs). | ||
* Updated records section now tracks Cools, Greats, Goods, and Bads you got in a song, in addition to score and max combo. | * Updated records section now tracks Cools, Greats, Goods, and Bads you got in a song, in addition to score and max combo. | ||
* Contains .5 speed-mods from [[ | * Contains .5 speed-mods from [[AC pnm 15|pop'n music 15 ADVENTURE]]. | ||
* Fast, easy unlocking system (if you know Japanese). | * Fast, easy unlocking system (if you know Japanese). | ||
* New Jukebox mode lets you to listen to songs in the game without playing / autoplaying them in Training Mode. | * New Jukebox mode lets you to listen to songs in the game without playing / autoplaying them in Training Mode. | ||
Line 262: | Line 260: | ||
'''Cons''' | '''Cons''' | ||
* Timing is considered too lax by some, making it easy to score on songs. | * Timing is considered too lax by some, making it easy to score on songs. | ||
* Only | * Only four revivals (ee'MALL songs aside). | ||
* Many of the ee'MALL songs have no EX charts. | * Many of the ee'MALL songs have no EX charts. | ||
* No Marathon Mode. | * No Marathon Mode. | ||
Line 268: | Line 266: | ||
* No Omake section. | * No Omake section. | ||
=== [[ | === [[CS pnm portable|pop'n music portable]] === | ||
'''Total Songs:''' 82<br> | '''Total Songs:''' 82<br> | ||
Line 274: | Line 272: | ||
'''Pros''' | '''Pros''' | ||
* Contains most of the non-CS/BEMANI crossovers songs from [[ | * Contains most of the non-CS/BEMANI crossovers songs from [[AC pnm 15|pop'n music 15 ADVENTURE]]. | ||
* First accurate portable pop'n music game, containing most of the original charts for new and old songs alike. | * First accurate portable pop'n music game, containing most of the original charts for new and old songs alike. | ||
* 5- | * 5-Button expanded on with HYPER charts. 7-Buttons returns for the first time since [[CS pnm 6|pop'n music 6 CS]], also with HYPER charts. | ||
* First pop'n music CS game with skins, a jukebox, and character bios. | * First pop'n music CS game with skins, a jukebox, and character bios. | ||
* Can be linked to [[ | * Can be linked to [[AC pnm 18|pop'n music 18 せんごく列伝]] to play a couple of the new CS songs on. | ||
* Brand-new, clean, easy-to-follow interface. | * Brand-new, clean, easy-to-follow interface. | ||
* 7 new songs, two of them brand-new licenses. | * 7 new songs, two of them brand-new licenses. | ||
Line 285: | Line 283: | ||
* Loading times are long, even moreso than the early PlayStation pop'n music games. | * Loading times are long, even moreso than the early PlayStation pop'n music games. | ||
* Only 82 songs, which is the smallest | * Only 82 songs, which is the smallest song list in a traditional CS pop'n game since [[CS pnm 5|pop'n music 5 CS]]. | ||
* Uncomfortable control scheme due to the game being on the PSP (though you can change the settings). | * Uncomfortable control scheme due to the game being on the PSP (though you can change the settings). | ||
* Lane slightly smaller and harder to read to fit on the PSP's monitor. | * Lane slightly smaller and harder to read to fit on the PSP's monitor. | ||
Line 293: | Line 291: | ||
* No Training Mode, and with it no way to autoplay songs. | * No Training Mode, and with it no way to autoplay songs. | ||
=== [[ | === [[CS pnm portable 2|pop'n music portable 2]] === | ||
'''Total Songs:''' 86 (146 with all DLC packs)<br> | '''Total Songs:''' 86 (146 with all DLC packs)<br> | ||
Line 299: | Line 297: | ||
'''Pros''' | '''Pros''' | ||
* Contains almost all of the songs from [[ | * Contains almost all of the songs from [[AC pnm 16|pop'n music 16 PARTY♪]]. | ||
* Loading times vastly improved from [[ | * Loading times vastly improved from [[CS pnm portable|pop'n music portable]], and you can download the game from PlayStation Network for even faster loading. | ||
* First non-Wii pop'n music title with DLC. | * First non-Wii pop'n music title with DLC. | ||
* You can now autoplay songs, unlike in the first portable. | * You can now autoplay songs, unlike in the first portable. | ||
* Party Mode doesn't force you to play 5-Button charts the entire time like Adventure Mode did. | * Party Mode doesn't force you to play 5-Button charts the entire time like Adventure Mode did. | ||
* Brand new charts for many pop'n music songs. | * Brand new charts for many pop'n music songs. | ||
* | * Four previews of later pop'n music arcade titles in-game, and several more for DLC. | ||
'''Cons''' | '''Cons''' | ||
* Two songs from PARTY♪ are only available as DLC, making the | * Two songs from PARTY♪ are only available as DLC, making the song list incomplete unless you pre-ordered the game. | ||
* Cools still cannot be turned off, regardless of mode. | * Cools still cannot be turned off, regardless of mode. | ||
* No licenses or ee'MALL songs. | * No licenses or ee'MALL songs. | ||
Line 316: | Line 314: | ||
{{stub}} | {{stub}} | ||
[[Category: | [[Category:pop'n music]] |