Talk:S-Bahn

Admin reply

Oh, you're the same guy I had to lock the If page because of last July. Okay, here we go again.

• "I know artist speculation has a special clause for BST entries, but" Exactly. It IS a special clause for the wiki, something that fellow admin GlaringRadiokid and I decided on a few months ago when we got tired of people for years throwing out speculations on near every hidden artist song on the wiki, BST or otherwise.
• "I feel like this exception to the rule is far more harmful to the implied factual nature of RemyWiki than it is good." How? RemyWiki has been speculating on artists and such for YEARS, and there aren't a lot of BST people to begin with.
• "I think it's pretty likely that it's TAKA given his SETUP from BERLIN alias" It sounds nothing like TAKA, who already has a song in the game. People thought Cosmic Cyber was TAKA back in Rootage because its genre was speculated to be a throwaway to his first BEMANI song GRADIUSIC CYBER, and because he did the first two songs in the CYBER series. That ended up not being true. Meanwhile, SYUNN has been around by default in every game since his IIDX debut, doesn't have a song otherwise on the default songlist, and S-Bahn sounds similar to a lot of his other, darker songs. You deleting it being SYUNN means you are doing a counter-edit, which IS against the rules of the wiki FYI.

I am locking the S-Bahn page for a week now. One more edit like this and you're temp banned for a week, Lain. Final warning. --M.B. (talk) 11:33, 3 November 2020 (UTC)

Talk

I know artist speculation has a special clause for BST entries, but this feels totally based on nothing. I feel like this exception to the rule is far more harmful to the implied factual nature of RemyWiki than it is good.

I think it's pretty likely that it's TAKA given his SETUP from BERLIN alias considering S-Bahn is the berlin rail network, but it's still very heavy speculation, the same as implying it's Syunn with no evidence.